I wrote this piece two years ago to honor my loss of my first dog, the legendary Spencer. I've reposted it here because try as I might, I don't think I could write anything more beautiful and right.
Three years ago on 3 July 2003, I euthanized my dog, the Legendary
Spencer. I quail a bit at the word “euthanize”; I find my chest
contracts at it. It’s an ugly word. To my mind, though, the euphemisms
are worse: put down like an insult or put to sleep like a child, as if
there is a time when he, my furry eternal toddler, will rise again.
Three years ago Spencer and I took our last walk. I leashed him, and
he looked at me with dying and hopeful eyes because he loved me and
because he loved walks. He unquestioningly went with me; he stepped
gingerly down the stairs of my apartment for the last time. For the
last time, I watched him pee, him no longer able to lift his leg. For
the last time, I saw him pause outside Bang! Bang! because one upon a
time the store had been another store, a store that unfailingly had
provided Spencer with biscuits, and he never, not even in his slightly
addled dotage, forgot a place that gave him biscuits.
For the last time I took him for a walk and for the last time he trusted me.
He was, unquestionably, ready to die. His kidneys were failing, and
his lung cancer had progressed to a point where he hacked and coughed
often and with a painful rawness; just breathing, for him, was
difficult. He had ceased to eat, even yummy treats like liverwurst. I
had, a few weeks earlier, had him shaved for the summer, something I
had never done before. I felt he was old and uncomfortable in the heat,
so I had brought him, also for the last time, to the groomer’s, which
he hated.
I bid adieu to his beautiful caramel sundae hair, the first bits of him I said good-bye to; the rest would come later.
And so three years ago for the last time, I brought him to his
vet’s, where she put us in a quiet room and then injected him with some
kind of preliminary downer, to get him to sleep before she gave him his
lethal dose of whatever.
He wouldn’t sleep there on the vet’s floor. He couldn’t. His body,
dehydrated from his failing kidneys, and his mind, nervous from being
at the vet’s, wouldn’t succumb to the soporific drugs. His eyes
remained open and he remained restive. Finally, unable to wait any
more, the vet just came in, and kindly and gently injected him with a
series of shots. He died in my lap.
I held him and cried, and then I clipped tufts of his ear hair,
which I have saved in a box. I also took ink prints of his left front
paw on rice paper. (I would, about a week later, walk back to the vet's
to pick up a white bakery box that read " Spencer, the loving pet of
Chelsea Girl." It still contains his ashes.)
I walked home from the vet’s alone. Alone I spent that night and the
next day, 4 July. The following day, I took the prints I had made of
Spencer’s paw after his death to a tattoo artist, and I had him tattoo
me with Spencer’s paw, his name and his dates on my right deltoid. It’s
not a very good tattoo—it wasn’t my usual artist, and I knew I’d regret
its ham-handed scarring depth—but I will never remove it.
I have lost friends, I have lost family members. I have never in my
life felt the keening grief I felt over losing my dog. I sobbed with
animal loss—deep, heaving, inarticulate moans of loss. I can’t even
write this today without tears. And I think that this grief is due to
the fact that people have disappointed me. People have created
conflict. People have given me qualified affection.
My dog never did. Sure, he made me angry. Once he ate the corner of
my then-roommate Becky Sue’s mattress. It was not a good day for either
of us. But Spencer was always unequivocally happy to see me. His love
for me was pure, and steady, and unqualified.
I was his God, he was my dog.
I remember in those first few weeks of insane grief, in those days
when all I wanted, all I really wanted was to be with him, how I felt
his fear of being removed from me, how I worried that no one would take
care of him wherever he was, and how I had a dream. In my dream, he and
I were out on a beautiful summer day, in a park that wasn’t a park, and
somehow we got separated.
I saw him across a wide expanse of very green grass and I called
him, but he didn’t come. He stood there, his long blonde and white hair
rippling in the breeze as I called and called, and then he walked, his
big Aussie butt twitching, away from me. In my dream, I remembered that
he was deaf, that he couldn’t hear me, but then I woke and I realized
that he had left because he was dead. He was gone, and I could never
call him back.
I don’t have a religious background. I don’t have a clear idea of an
afterlife, of a heaven or a hell or even a reincarnation. However, in
my hopes, if I live a good life, if I’m moral and take responsibility
for my mistakes, if I treat my neighbor as myself, and apologize when I
do not, then I shall at my life’s end be reunited with Spencer.
In a perfect world, dogs like him would never die. In a perfect
world, I would never have known this loss. But in a less perfect world,
I console myself, I would never have known his love.
Spencer T. Jones 11/27/90-7/3/03